Skip to main content

How we rate credit cards

This page explains how we choose the cards we cover, how we score them, where the facts come from, and how we make money. The scoring method is our own, and any score built from it is our opinion.

Which cards we cover

We cover 42 popular U.S. personal cards from American Express, Chase, Capital One, Discover, Citi, Wells Fargo, Bank of America, Barclays and U.S. Bank. We chose them to cover the main card types: cash back, flat-rate, travel, starter and secured, student, and 0% intro APR. This is a selection, not the whole market.

We also cover 10 small business cards. They appear only in our business list, on their own review pages and in the compare tool, never in our personal lists, card list or finder.

Our five rating criteria

Each card gets a score from 0 to 5 on five criteria. The overall score is the weighted average. Every input is a field in our card records: facts from the issuer's own pages, plus the credit level the issuer states or, where it states none, our labeled estimate. Nothing else goes into the math.

CriterionWeightHow we score it
Rewards value35%Yearly rewards on our reference budget of $24,000 (business cards: a $60,000 business budget), with points and miles at 1 cent each (hotel program points at 0.5 cent). Earning 3% of the budget or more scores 5.
Fees20%A $0 annual fee scores 5, falling in a straight line to 0 at $700. A foreign transaction fee takes off half a point.
Intro APR15%Months at 0%, up to 21. Balance transfer months count for 60% and purchase months for 40%, because a transfer helps with debt you already have.
Credit accessibility15%How easy the card is to qualify for, from the credit level the issuer states or our estimate: building 5, fair 4, good 3, excellent 2.
Simplicity15%Starts at 5. We take off 1.5 for rotating categories you must activate, 1 for points or miles instead of cash, 1 for more than three reward tiers, and 0.5 when the top rate needs a booking portal.

The reference budget

To compare rewards fairly, we run every card through the same yearly spending of $24,000. Each line earns the card's best stated rate for that category, or its stated rate on everything else. A rate you earn in one category of your choice counts once, where it earns the most. Rates that need the issuer's booking site, or that apply only to the card's own airline or hotel, count on half of the travel line. For cards with rotating 5% categories, we assume $2,000 of the "everything else" line lands in them.

  • Groceries$5,000
  • Dining out$3,000
  • Gas$2,000
  • Travel$2,000
  • Online shopping$3,000
  • Streaming$600
  • Everything else$8,400

The business budget

Business cards earn on costs a household budget doesn't have, so we score their rewards on a separate yearly business budget of $60,000, about $5,000 a month, with the same rules as above. A rate the card applies each billing cycle to the categories where you spent the most counts on the budget lines where it earns the most, as if you spent the same every month. The rewards score scales to this budget, so a business card's score compares only with other business cards.

  • Advertising$6,000
  • Software and cloud services$3,000
  • Internet, cable and phone$2,400
  • Shipping$2,400
  • Office supplies$2,400
  • Travel$6,000
  • Dining out$3,000
  • Gas$3,000
  • Everything else$31,800

What the score leaves out

  • Points and miles count at 1 cent each, and hotel program points at 0.5 cent, because hotel programs award more points per dollar. You can sometimes get more through transfer partners or award bookings, and sometimes less.
  • Statement credits, lounge access, free night awards, free checked bags, companion fares, elite status and other perks are not scored, because their value depends on whether you use them. That is why premium travel cards with fees near or above $700 score low here even when their perks may be worth it to you.
  • When a bonus rate's cap is shared by several categories and our budget for them goes past it, the rate counts only up to that cap, and the rest earns the card's next best rate. Other caps sit above our budget amounts. Only rates the issuer states count.
  • Intro APRs count up to 21 months. The regular APR after the intro period is not scored, because most cards quote similar ranges and your rate depends on your credit.

A score is a starting point for comparing cards, not a verdict. The best card for you depends on how you spend and pay. Our card finder ranks cards against your own answers instead.

How our best-of lists work

Each best-of list has its own rule for which cards qualify and its own weights over the five criteria above, so a list reflects what matters for that need. Only cards checked in the last 30 days appear. Ties go to the lower annual fee. Referral status is never an input, and a unit test checks every list by flipping it.

We publish a list only while at least 3 fitting cards have a recent check.

Lists by credit level

Our lists by credit level include cards whose credit level is at or below yours. We use the issuer's own wording where it gives one and our estimate otherwise, labeled as such on each card. For building and fair credit we weight how easy a card is to get more heavily; for good and excellent credit we use the overall rating.

These lists are not approval odds. Approval isn't guaranteed. Issuers decide based on your full profile.

Where our facts come from

We read card facts only on each issuer's official product page and its pricing and terms. We summarize them in our own words and never take text, ratings or data from other comparison sites. If an issuer page does not show a fact, we leave it blank rather than guess.

We aim to re-read every card's issuer page weekly. The checked date on each card shows when we last did, and each card links to that page. If a card's check is more than 30 days old, our card list hides it by default (you can choose "Include older checks"), and the compare page and finder mark it "Needs a fresh check". Terms can change at any time, so confirm them on the issuer's site before you apply.

How we make money

Some links may pay us a referral bonus. Right now that applies to 4 cards:

  • The Platinum Card from American Express
  • American Express Gold Card
  • Chase Freedom Flex
  • Capital One Venture X Rewards

Their buttons say "Apply through our link", go through our tracked redirect, and are marked as sponsored. All other cards link straight to the issuer, and we earn nothing from them.

Referrals never change our order. The rating formula, the card list's sort and the finder's ranking never read whether a card pays us. An automated test checks this on every change: it flips every card between referral and non-referral and confirms the finder's order stays the same. Read our full disclosure.

What we don't do

  • We don't show approval odds or say you are pre-approved or prequalified. Only the issuer can decide, and approval is never guaranteed.
  • We don't run credit checks or ask for your name, income, address, email or Social Security number.
  • Your finder answers never leave your browser. We don't send, save or track them. We count page views and clicks on referral links, never your answers.

Educational information, not financial advice.