Skip to main content

American Express Gold Card vs. The Platinum Card from American Express

Issuer facts side by side, our scores, and the spending at which a higher fee starts to pay off. Which card fits depends on where you spend, so we list who each one suits instead of naming a winner.

Where the fee pays off

In our model, the Platinum Card from American Express's $570 higher annual fee does not pay for itself in rewards at any spending level up to $250,000 a year. Its case rests on perks and credits we don't score.

How we work this out: yearly rewards minus the ongoing annual fee (first-year waivers left out), with spending split like our $24,000 sample budget and scaled up or down. Points and miles count at 1 cent each, and stated spending caps apply. Welcome offers, perks and credits are not included. How we rate cards.

Pick the American Express Gold Card if…

  • you spend roughly like our $24,000 sample budget: it comes out about $790 a year ahead after its annual fee, before perks.
  • you want the lower annual fee: $325 against $895.
  • you spend a lot on dining out: 4X points (up to a spending cap), against 1X points on the other card.
  • you spend a lot on groceries: 4X points (up to a spending cap), against 1X points on the other card.

Pick the Platinum Card from American Express if…

  • you spend a lot on flights booked directly with airlines or through American Express Travel: 5X points (up to a spending cap), against 3X points on the other card.

American Express Gold Card and The Platinum Card from American Express have perks, credits or travel benefits that our scores and break-even leave out. If you'll use them, they can outweigh the numbers here.

American Express Gold Card and The Platinum Card from American Express side by side
DetailAmerican Express Gold CardThe Platinum Card from American Express
TypeTravel and premiumTravel and premium
Annual fee$325$895
Rewards
  • 4X points Restaurants worldwide, on up to $50,000 a calendar year, then 1X
  • 4X points U.S. supermarkets, on up to $25,000 a calendar year, then 1X
  • 5X points Prepaid hotels booked through AmexTravel.com
  • 3X points Flights booked directly with airlines or through AmexTravel.com
  • 1X points Other eligible purchases
  • 5X points Flights booked directly with airlines or through American Express Travel, on up to $500,000 a calendar year
  • 5X points Prepaid hotels booked through American Express Travel
  • 1X points Other purchases
Welcome offerVaries by applicant. The public page says as high as 100,000 Membership Rewards points after $8,000 in purchases in 6 months; Amex shows your offer when you apply.Varies by applicant. The public page says as high as 175,000 Membership Rewards points after $12,000 in purchases in 6 months; Amex shows your offer when you apply.
Intro APRNot stated on the issuer pageNot stated on the issuer page
Regular APR19.74% to 28.74% variable on Pay Over Time charges19.74% to 28.74% variable on Pay Over Time charges
Foreign transaction feeNoneNone
Credit levelOur estimate: excellent credit. Approval isn't guaranteed.Our estimate: excellent credit. Approval isn't guaranteed.
Best for (our opinion)People who spend a lot on restaurants and groceries and want transferable points.Frequent flyers who will use airport lounges and enough of the statement credits to cover a large fee.
Watch out (our opinion)Several credits arrive in small monthly amounts at specific merchants. Count only the ones you already use.The fee is among the highest on the market, and many credits are monthly or need enrollment, so unused credits are lost value.
Apply and sources

Info checked . Confirm terms on the issuer's site.

Issuer source for American Express Gold Card

Info checked . Confirm terms on the issuer's site.

Issuer source for The Platinum Card from American Express

Facts come from issuer pages and can change at any time. Some links may pay us a referral bonus; that does not change the facts, scores or reasons on this page. Read our disclosure.

Educational information, not financial advice.