How to compare bank bonuses: the dollars you actually keep
本文暂时只有英文版本。

A bank bonus is useful only if you qualify and keep enough of it after fees, taxes and any interest you give up. Start with your normal cash flow, not the biggest headline. Our offer comparison page puts the requirements and deadlines beside each other.
First, eliminate offers you cannot earn
Read the eligibility rules on the exact application page. Existing customers, recent bonus recipients and people outside a bank's service area may be excluded. A promotional code or specific application link may be required.
For example, U.S. Bank's offer terms exclude people with an existing consumer checking account, one held in the previous 12 months, or a checking bonus in the previous 12 months. Its geographic restrictions also matter. Those rules come before any comparison of bonus size.
Direct deposits are not the same as savings you must park
Write down three separate numbers: the opening deposit, the total qualifying deposits and any balance you must maintain. Do not add them together without reading the terms; the same money may satisfy more than one requirement.
U.S. Bank requires at least two qualifying payroll or government-benefit deposits and online or mobile banking enrollment. Wells Fargo defines qualifying electronic deposits differently and excludes ordinary account transfers and Zelle. A transfer that works at one bank is not proof it works at another.
Plan the timing around when deposits actually post. Save the terms and offer code when you open the account.
Compare net dollars with a simple worksheet
Use this estimate:
Bonus minus unavoidable fees minus estimated tax on the bonus minus interest forgone elsewhere.
Here is a hypothetical example, not a live offer or a tax-rate recommendation. Suppose the bonus is $300, you expect $30 of fees, and you use a 24% tax assumption. If you must hold $5,000 for 90 days in an account earning nothing instead of an account earning 4% APY:
- Estimated tax on the bonus: $300 × 24% = $72.
- Forgone interest: $5,000 × (1.04^(90/365) − 1), approximately $48.59.
- Estimated net benefit: $300 − $30 − $72 − $48.59 = $149.41.
This deliberately uses pretax forgone interest, so it is a conservative simplification; it ignores tax on alternative interest, timing and rate changes. Replace every assumption with your own figures. If the bonus account earns interest, subtract only the difference. If no balance hold is required, do not invent one.
Both Wells Fargo's terms and U.S. Bank's terms say the bonus is reported for tax purposes. Your actual tax treatment depends on your circumstances.
Estimate what you keep
Illustrative starting values, not a live offer. Use 0 for the held balance if no hold is required. All calculations stay in your browser.
- Estimated net benefit
- $149.41
- Estimated bonus tax
- $72.00
- Forgone interest
- $48.59
Estimate = bonus − fees − tax on bonus − forgone interest. Interest uses APY compounding over days/365 at a constant balance and rate. Forgone interest is pretax and floored at zero; extra interest from a higher-paying bonus account is not counted. Taxes on account interest, payout timing, changing balances, eligibility and your time are not modeled. Your actual tax rate may differ.
Separate the bonus rule from the fee waiver
Earning a bonus does not necessarily waive the monthly fee. Wells Fargo's page explicitly separates those requirements. U.S. Bank's page describes an initial fee waiver followed by ongoing waiver conditions.
Make a short checklist: application deadline, deposit deadline, fee-waiver rule, expected payout window and any holding or closure conditions. Keep enough cash in your normal account for bills while changing payroll instructions.
Check the link, then decide
On November 15, 2026, Wells Fargo's linked official page showed $325, while our earlier coverage discussed reports of a $500 version. A larger number elsewhere does not change the terms attached to your application.
Choose the offer whose rules you can satisfy with your existing cash flow and whose net value justifies the effort. Recheck the official page before applying; our comparison hub shows when each offer was last checked.

