Secured card vs credit-builder loan: which way to start credit
本文暂时只有英文版本。

If you are starting credit from scratch, two of the tools the CFPB lists are a secured credit card and a credit-builder loan. Both can report your payments to the three credit bureaus, but they work in opposite directions: a secured card needs your cash first, while a credit-builder loan holds the money for you and pays it out at the end.
How a secured credit card works
With a secured card, you put down a cash deposit. The CFPB's example is $500. You can then spend up to that amount, and when you pay the bill, your available spending goes back up to the amount you put in.
How a credit-builder loan works
A credit-builder loan comes from a bank or credit union, and you don't get the money up front. According to the CFPB's 2020 guide on these loans:
- You don't make an opening deposit. The lender puts its own money, equal to the loan amount, into a locked savings account.
- You make monthly payments, which the CFPB says usually run six to 24 months.
- At the end, the lender releases the money to you, minus any interest or fees.
- Typical loan sizes are about $300 to $1,000, though terms vary by lender.
The lender reports your payment history to the three major credit bureaus as an installment loan, a loan with fixed payments over a set term. So you build a payment record and end up with savings at the same time.
Side by side
| Secured credit card | Credit-builder loan | |
|---|---|---|
| Money up front | You deposit cash (for example, $500) | No opening deposit |
| What you get | A card you can spend up to your deposit | Funds released after you finish paying |
| Typical length | Ongoing | Usually 6 to 24 months |
| Reported to bureaus as | A credit card | An installment loan |
The catch: late payments still count
In a CFPB-funded study of a credit union's credit-builder loan, about 40% of people who opened one made at least one late payment, even though their payments went straight into their own savings. The CFPB suggests some borrowers may not have understood how the loan worked or simply forgot the due date.
The same study found that people with no existing debt tended to benefit more than people already juggling other loans. Some borrowers with existing debt fell behind on their other bills.
How to use these tools
- Pick the one you can pay on time, every time. Both products report your payments, late ones included.
- Ask whether the payments are reported to all three credit bureaus before you sign up.
- Check the interest and fees on a credit-builder loan, since they come out of what you get back.
- Set autopay or a reminder for the due date from the first month.
- Think about your other bills first. If you already have debts, make sure a new monthly payment fits your budget.
Terms vary by bank and credit union, and these products are not right for everyone. The CFPB pages linked above explain more ways to start or rebuild credit.
Photo by Marissa Daeger on Unsplash
Not financial advice.


