Closing an old credit card: why your utilization can jump

Closing a credit card you never use can feel like tidying up. But it removes that card's credit limit from your total. If you carry balances on other cards, your credit utilization can rise even though you didn't spend another dollar.
What utilization means
Credit utilization is the share of your available revolving credit that you're using. It's part of the "amounts owed" category, which myFICO says makes up about 30% of a FICO Score. In general, lower utilization is better for your scores.
Utilization is a ratio, so it changes when either side changes. Paying down a balance lowers it. Losing available credit raises it.
The myFICO example
myFICO walks through a simple case with three cards:
- Before: total balances of $2,000 against total limits of $6,500, which is about 30% utilization.
- After closing card B, an unused card with a $3,000 limit, the balances are still $2,000. Total limits drop to $3,500.
- New utilization: $2,000 / $3,500 = 57%.
Nothing about the person's spending changed. The jump from 30% to 57% comes only from the lost limit.
What closing doesn't do right away
A common myth is that a closed card's history disappears from your score immediately. myFICO says FICO Scores generally consider the age of both open and closed accounts, as long as the account remains on your credit report. So the main short-term risk is usually utilization, not account age.
When closing can still make sense
There are real reasons to close a card. Maybe it has an annual fee you don't want to pay, you're tempted to overspend, or a lender has asked you to close it. myFICO notes that if you are planning to apply for credit soon, it's worth thinking about timing, because a score dip right before an application can matter.
If your balances are already $0 across all your cards, closing an unused card has less effect on utilization, since zero divided by anything is still zero.
How to use this before you close a card
- Add up your balances and limits across all your cards, then do the math with and without the card you want to close. Our free credit utilization calculator does this for you.
- Pay balances down first if closing the card would push your utilization noticeably higher.
- Ask about a no-fee version if the annual fee is your only reason for closing. Some issuers offer a product change.
- Hold off before a big application, like a mortgage or auto loan, if you can.
- Keep using old no-fee cards occasionally if you decide to keep them open, so the issuer doesn't close them for inactivity.
Scoring models differ, and the exact effect on your score depends on your whole credit file. The myFICO example shows the idea, not a prediction of your score.
Photo by Emil Kalibradov on Unsplash
Not financial advice.


